Holden, others offer advice for Nixon

Tough economy means new governor will need solid relationship with legislature
Sunday, January 4, 2009 | 7:13 p.m. CST; updated 2:13 p.m. CST, Thursday, January 22, 2009

JEFFERSON CITY — With an apparent replay of the budget and political environment of the last administration, former top leaders from both major political parties have different advice for Missouri Gov.-elect Jay Nixon. He will be inaugurated at the state Capitol on Jan. 12.

Like former one-term Democratic Gov. Bob Holden, Nixon will face a budget shortfall and a Republican-controlled legislature.  Six years ago, the budget crisis led to a political nightmare. Holden refused to propose a budget that could be balanced with existing revenue, and the Republican legislature rejected his proposals for tax increases.

“What I hope that everybody learned from the years I was in the governor's office is that political rhetoric does not solve problems,” Holden said in a recent interview reflecting on his administration.

Late in 2008, the state of Missouri was officially declared to be in an economic recession. Nixon's budget adviser has predicted a $342 million budget shortfall for fiscal year 2009, which ends June 30.

Holden faced Missouri's worst economy since the nationwide recession of the early 1990s. The state was officially in recession in November 2001, following the first depressed quarter in 10 years and the sudden economic downturn because of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.

“We became aware of how tight the budget was,” Holden said. “We very early on realized that the leadership of the House and the Senate under the Republicans' control — the atmosphere was gridlock. The strategy was not to solve the problems but to leave them at the governor’s doorstep, which I think was unfortunate for the state."

One year after taking office, Holden faced a budget deficit approaching $1 billion, a situation he tried to address through multiple budget cuts and proposed tax increases. But his efforts to boost revenue met stiff opposition from the Republican legislative leadership.

Years later, Holden still expresses frustration. Asked whether it would be wise for Nixon to try to raise taxes, Holden said Nixon simply needs to analyze the situation seriously.

“That's a decision that every governor has to think about candidly and at their own peril, because the public doesn’t understand the situation,” Holden said. “People want more services at less cost, and we’re all that way in everything we do in life.”

Jason Crowell, the 2004 House Republican floor leader, said Nixon should not pursue a tax hike.

“I don't think we're going to be able to tax-increase our way to prosperity," said Crowell, now a Republican state senator from Cape Girardeau. “That's what Gov. Holden wanted to do. Missourians said, ‘No, you’re not raising taxes; you’re going to live within your means.’ And under Gov. (Matt) Blunt, that’s what we did.”

Before the recent economic downturn took its toll, Blunt’s administration produced a $281 million surplus, in contrast to the $1 billion deficit Holden encountered seven years ago.

Chairman of the House Budget Committee in 2004, St. Charles Republican Carl Beaden agreed with Crowell. 

“I think that today’s environment is very similar to the environment we faced a couple of years ago, with some differences about the ongoing economic slowdown,” Bearden said. “But a Democratic governor could begin by proposing a budget that doesn’t increase spending by a tremendous amount.”

Nixon will take office during what could be the worst economic recession since the Great Depression, said his transition budget adviser, former Sen. Wayne Goode. Goode chaired both the House and Senate budget-writing committees during his decades of service in the legislature.

But there is no easy solution, regardless of who is working alongside you, Bearden said.

“There are still a lot of challenges out there,” Bearden said. “There’s not a magic wand that we wave; there’s not a person who’s a superman or a superwoman who can solve this.

“I think he’s got a start with someone who knows the system at least, and then hopefully they will make some good recommendations about the places that can be reduced, while increasing others,” Bearden said.

Like Holden, Nixon will enter office as a Democratic governor facing a Republican majority in both the House and Senate.

Republican leaders during Holden’s gubernatorial term point to party politics and ineffective communication as dividing the General Assembly from the governor's office.

Crowell said a gag order that Holden issued to his office staff was the biggest source of conflict between the General Assembly and the governor’s office. Because the governor’s staff was restricted from communicating directly with the General Assembly, Crowell said legislators lacked the resources to make completely informed decisions.

“Our position was always, ‘This is not the governor's information — this is the people’s information, this is the state of Missouri’s information,’” Crowell said. “And it did cause issues and caused us to craft a budget that probably wasn't as good as Missourians deserved, because the governor wouldn’t cooperate with sharing information with department heads or other individuals.”

Crowell said the House tried to combat the gag order by investigating it.

“But that was stonewalled by the administration, all the way up to and through the Joint Committee of Legislative Hearings and Oversight,” Crowell said.

Holden said he tried to connect with Republicans in the General Assembly but that, in retrospect, he could not have treated the Republicans any differently.

“It was obvious that the leadership was more interested in looking at it through political eyes than governmental eyes,” Holden said. “They made the decision that there was not going to be room for compromise, and that’s unfortunate because I think you do need, in our political process, a sense of compromise.”

Rod Jetton, who was speaker pro tem of the House during part of Holden’s term, said the different parties simply had different agendas.

“Clearly, when you have two different parties in control, you’re going to pass much less legislation than you would have if you had the same party in control, because things are just going to roll quicker,” said Jetton, whose tenure as House speaker is about to end. “But sometimes that’s not the best thing. It’s the best thing to have a compromise."

Leaders from both parties encourage strong communication as an effective starting point for Nixon.

Crowell said Holden was not interested in one-on-one discussions with Republicans. He also said he appreciates Nixon’s propensity to reach out to various leaders. Nixon, for example, has invited Senate and House leaders to his office since the election.

“I think he is a leader of a different cloth and wants to discuss and communicate — and where we disagree, we disagree,” Crowell said. “That's healthy. Boy, what a boring world this would be if everyone thought and agreed with me.”

Holden said his first priority if elected now would be to seek discussion and common ground with leaders from both parties.

“If there is no agreement there to want to try and solve a problem, it’s hard to negotiate your own demise,” Holden said. “And that's the situation I found myself in as governor.”

Jetton said party politics should play a lesser role next year because Republicans have held the legislative majority through the terms of governors from each party.

“I think now that we’ve been through this party switching in the past eight years a little bit more, now people realize that you’re not going to get your way,” Jetton said. “You're going to have to work with the other side.”


Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.