Critics question Army's response to drug abuse cases

Wednesday, January 21, 2009 | 5:20 p.m. CST; updated 8:46 p.m. CST, Wednesday, January 21, 2009

FORT LEONARD WOOD — Spec. Jeremiah Thomson didn't know what was worse: excruciating back pain from a combat explosion in Baghdad or the prescription drug addiction he developed trying to ease the suffering once home.

Military drug use summary

  • WOUNDED TROOPS: Legal painkiller use by injured troops has increased nearly 70 percent since the start of the Iraq war, the Army says. As more soldiers seek help with prescription drug addiction, the Army is struggling to hire enough drug counselors to meet the increased demand.
  • BLACK MARKET: An investigation at Fort Leonard Wood revealed a group of soldiers who illegally bought and sold Percocet, Oxycontin, Vicodin and other powerful painkillers. The investigation ensnared more than two dozen soldiers.
  • CONGRESSIONAL INQUIRY: A whistle-blower who worked in the Army Substance Abuse Program took his concerns to Sen. Claire McCaskill, a Missouri Democrat. She has asked Army Secretary Pete Geren to investigate.

The Army was quick to prescribe Percocet, Vicodin, Oxycontin and similarly powerful painkillers to Thomson and other injured soldiers at Fort Leonard Wood, Thomson testified in a court-martial hearing. He's now serving a three-year sentence for illegally buying prescription drugs — the sellers included a former commanding officer in Iraq — and selling the pills to eight other soldiers.

As more troops return home with war injuries, the Army is prescribing more pain medication to treat those wounds. But a military system that relies on discipline as well as treatment is drawing fire from some prominent critics, including those inside the system.

"It's a terrible problem," said Barbara McDonald, a civilian social worker and Army drug abuse counselor, describing a recent surge in prescription drug abuse and the Army's handling of the problem.

Legal painkiller use by injured troops has increased nearly 70 percent since the start of the Iraq war six years ago, according to Army records. Surveys show that more soldiers are struggling with prescription drug addiction — and seeking help from Army doctors and counselors.

Thomson is among seven soldiers convicted by court martial in 2008 of illegal drug use or distribution who served in the installation's 5th Engineer Battalion. The unit supports combat troops by building and guarding roads and bridges and repairing vehicles. An additional five await trial on similar charges. A dozen have been kicked out of the Army, and two others went AWOL after being implicated in the investigation.

Les McFarling, who heads the Army's substance abuse treatment program, acknowledges the increased potential for abuse.

"You can put soldiers at risk when you're managing their pain," he said.

But McDonald and other critics call the military's approach a broken system, as likely to punish or denigrate troops as to treat their addictions.

The criminal cases in Missouri, coupled with allegations of misconduct and staffing shortages in the Army Substance Abuse Program levied by McDonald and another whistle-blower, caught the attention of Sen. Claire McCaskill, D-Mo. She has asked Secretary of the Army Pete Geren to investigate.

"Clearly, at Fort Leonard Wood and potentially across the military, they have not prioritized this as a health issue," McCaskill said. "The culture has traditionally looked at this as a discipline issue."

Under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, such punishments can include reductions in rank and pay, imprisonment and discharges from military service for bad conduct.

The Army says those disciplined in the Fort Leonard Wood investigation committed criminal misconduct by selling or illegally possessing drugs, as opposed to those who become dependent on narcotics prescribed for legitimate injuries.

"A soldier who steps forward is someone who should be admired, not as someone with a black mark next to their name," McCaskill said.

In a Dec. 22 response to McCaskill's inquiry, Geren indicated the Army will consider abolishing its policy that a commanding officer be notified when a soldier comes forward voluntarily for ASAP counseling.

Still, officials at Fort Leonard Wood and the Pentagon defend their approach, even as they acknowledge staffing shortages that have left ASAP nationwide nearly 90 counselors short of required employment levels. Staffing levels at the Missouri post are now above the required minimums, the Army says.

McDonald disputes that, saying at least one recently hired counselor for Fort Leonard Wood's ASAP unit lacks required mental health certification. Army officials did not respond to a request for comment on her assertion.

Army statistics show that the number of soldiers enrolled in ASAP at Fort Leonard Wood at the end of 2008 was the highest since the start of the Iraq war six years ago.

McCaskill's office learned of the problems at Fort Leonard Wood from former ASAP counselor John Speckhals, a Vietnam veteran and former Veterans Administration social worker now stationed in Germany. Speckhals declined an AP request for an interview.

An inquiry by the senator's office said as many as 180 cases referred to the base's ASAP unit were misclassified in what McCaskill suggested in a Nov. 12 letter to Geren were "deliberate clinical findings that soldiers who were dependent on alcohol or drugs were not dependent in order to keep the caseload down for an overwhelmed staff."

"There was an effort to give a cosmetic fix to a problem that was systemic," McCaskill said in an interview.

In his letter to McCaskill, Geren said a review of those cases and 17 others showed some record-keeping errors, but no evidence that cases were deliberately mislabeled.

"Virtually all soldiers were offered some further assistance or referral," Geren wrote.

McDonald, whose son is a soldier, spent 20 years as a civilian substance abuse counselor before joining the Army's fight against drug and alcohol abuse one year ago. She has filed a workplace complaint against her supervisor and faces disciplinary action she says stems from her criticisms. Army officials have not commented.

McDonald claims that some Army doctors and counselors point to drug dependency as a sign of weakness. Since McDonald's complaints surfaced, she is no longer allowed to see patients.

Lori Mullins of Idaho Falls, Idaho, said her 18-year-old daughter, Destiny, was told McDonald had quit and that McDonald was told Destiny Mullins no longer wanted treatment.

"They told (Destiny) she didn't belong in the military, that she was a shame to the uniform," Lori Mullins said. "Instead of being protected by the Army, they're blaming her for it."

Destiny Mullins received an honorable discharge in November.

Chuck Ashbrook, who oversees ASAP prevention and education efforts at Fort Leonard Wood, maintained that counselors pay close attention to links between substance abuse, post-traumatic stress disorder and combat injuries.

He said that, thanks to medical advances, soldiers who might have returned from previous conflicts as casualties are instead surviving with injuries that might require stronger pain management.

However, Ashbrook also noted historical increases in drug dependency among soldiers during wartime.

"We've always seen these kind of problems," he said. "This is not unique."

Thomson, a tank mechanic whose father and both grandfathers were enlisted men, said he was diagnosed with an autoimmune disease after being injured from repeated blasts of improvised explosive devices while deployed in Iraq in 2006.

The pain left him bedridden and short of breath, he testified at his trial in April. But nothing prepared him for the withdrawal after his supply of painkillers ran out.

"I had sweats, cold sweats, shakes, vomiting, nausea (and) extreme pain where it was even worse than before I had ever taken the medication," he said.

Asked by a military prosecutor if commanding officers had referred him to the ASAP unit, Thomson said no, even after testing positive for cocaine use while in treatment. He wasn't even aware the unit existed until a friend was sent, he said.

Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Charles Dudley Jr January 22, 2009 | 2:21 a.m.

Prayers up for all of our injured soldiers who are suffering the effects of drug addiction and the traumas of war injuries.

It is not easy living with physical and mental pain on a daily basis by far.

(Report Comment)
robin souers February 7, 2009 | 11:17 p.m.

The Army's Substance Abuse Program offers little more than social control. It's possible that some of the problems reported at Leonard Wood are driven by "mission requirements" ---the need to keep warm bodies in green suits. The ASAP is governed by AR 600-85, which requires that "soldiers diagnosed as being drug dependent by a physician will be detoxified and then processed for administrative separation in accordance with appropriate enlisted or officer separation regulations, and be considered for disciplinary action under the UCMJ." (10-6, c. (2)). This is from a brand new major revision to this document that makes blood-letting appear enlightened by comparison. Alas, so many agendas, so little wisdom...

(Report Comment)
Marie Smith August 10, 2010 | 10:55 a.m.

Great article! has compiled a comprehensive listing of accredited substance abuse treatment facilities and their services and licensed <a href="">drug counselors</a> in the continental US to give all parties access to detailed information of treatment facilities and clinicians. Visit to find the right treatment for you and get on your way to the road of recovery!

(Report Comment)

Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.