Israeli war against Hamas scars Gaza's children

Sunday, January 25, 2009 | 5:06 p.m. CST

JEBALIYA, Gaza Strip— Surrounded by mountains of rubble that were once their homes, two dozen children sat on a rainbow-colored blanket and drew with crayons.

They quickly filled the pages passed around by trauma counselors with pictures of Israeli tanks, dead bodies and Palestinians firing assault rifles — scenes they saw when Israel's war on Hamas came into their neighborhood.

"We felt we will die soon," 11-year-old Sharif Abed Rabbo told the group, describing his family's escape. "And I am sad I lost my house."

Psychologists say Israel's three-week offensive inflicted more severe trauma than previous conflicts in Gaza because civilians in the crowded sliver of territory had no safe place to run. A wartime study among hundreds of Gaza children showed a rise in nightmares, bedwetting and other signs of trauma, said psychologist Fadel Abu Hein.

Counselors and aid workers fear Gaza's children, who make up 56 percent of the 1.4 million people here, will grow up hating Israel and become easier prey for extremists.

"We are losing the next generation," said John Ging, the top U.N. aid official in Gaza. As a buffer against militancy, U.N. schools are launching human rights classes for their 200,000 students this week.

Children and teens were particularly vulnerable in Israel's military offensive, launched Dec. 27 to try to halt eight years of Hamas rocket fire on towns in southern Israel. The rocket attacks have frightened children there and frequently sent them running for cover.

In Gaza, the Palestinian Center for Human Rights counted 280 children among 1,285 dead and said one in four of the more than 4,000 wounded was a minor.

Facing the Israeli invasion, Hamas gunmen often operated from densely populated Gaza neighborhoods, drawing massive Israeli fire that killed and wounded large numbers of civilians, along with fighters. Tens of thousands fled their homes, seeking shelter in U.N. schools.

Among the refugees was Ansam Rahel, 10, who fled shelling of her home in the town of Beit Lahiya and sought cover, along with her family, in the town's U.N. school. On Jan. 17, when an Israeli shell struck the shelter, Ansam was hit by shrapnel that sliced across the top of her head. A thick welt of stitches runs diagonally across her partially shaved scalp, and she covers it with a ski cap.

The little girl, who carries herself with quiet grace and sadness, is back home, but her life has changed. Her father is in Egypt, where her 5-year-old sister Dima is undergoing treatment for a serious war injury. Ansam said she takes painkillers and doesn't sleep well.

On Saturday, she briefly returned to her school to say goodbye to friends. She is not well enough to attend and was told by school officials she might be taken to France for further medical treatment. "I didn't let them cry or feel pity for me," she said of her classmates.

Abu Hein, a psychologist who runs a community health center in Gaza City, said his teams interviewed 950 families, among them 2,180 children, in U.N. shelters across Gaza during and after the war.

A majority of parents told the team their children had become more clingy, and about one-third said their children insisted on sleeping in the same room with them.

Since a cease-fire took hold a week ago, Abu Hein's center and other aid groups have sent teams to the most devastated areas, seeking out children for emergency counseling.

On Sunday, three of his counselors drove to the Abed Rabbo neighborhood of the town of Jebaliya, a few hundred yards from the Israeli border. The neighborhood came under heavy fire during Israel's ground offensive, which began Jan. 3. House after house in a radius of hundreds of yards was destroyed, with nothing left except mountains of rubble.

The counselors spread a large blanket on a small patch of grass, and children soon came running. About two dozen, from toddlers to young teens, sat in a circle and played games, raising their hands or clapping, to break the ice. A counselor then asked the older kids to tell what happened to them during the war.

Asra Aref, 8, said her father raised a white flag when soldiers came closer and spoke Hebrew to them. "The soldiers told him he has just five minutes to evacuate the house," she said.

Counselor Farraj al-Hau tried to assure the children, especially the boys, that it's OK to be scared, that he was also frightened during the war.

Then he asked the children to draw. The youngest ones just managed a few squiggles, but almost all the drawings of the older ones included tanks, helicopters or bodies sprawled on the ground. One boy drew a Palestinian gunman firing an assault rifle at a tank. In another picture, two blue dots meant to be land mines were planted under tanks.

At one point, 5-year-old Saja Abed Rabbo, in pigtails and pajamas, started crying. Counselor Mustafa Haj-Ahmed led her away and sat with her on a nearby chunk of cement, gently asking her what happened. She barely spoke.

Haj-Ahmed walked with her and a relative to her wrecked home. Her grandfather, Mohammed, explained that the family, Saja among them, came under heavy fire in the house for three days before fleeing. He said Saja saw the bodies of two cousins, ages 13 and 14, who were killed in the fighting.

The counselors said they'd return to the neighborhood for more intensive counseling.

Gaza's 221 U.N. schools are also trying to help the children cope. On Saturday, the first day of school, teachers asked students to share their stories.

The weekly human rights classes will include lessons about nonviolent ways of solving conflicts. Ging said the new program had been planned for awhile, but now has greater urgency.

"We have to stand with the mothers and fathers who want their children to grow up to be doctors, lawyers and civilized in their behavior and their thinking," Ging said. "But for sure, the circumstances here, day by day, are working against all of us who have that agenda."

For 14-year-old Zakariya Baroud, the trauma is still too real. He lost three classmates in an Israeli mortar attack that killed 42 people, most of them civilians, near a U.N. school in the Jebaliya refugee camp. Israel said at the time that troops were firing at a Palestinian rocket squad in the area.

Zakariya said he saw bodies strewn across the main road, including that of his best friend, Bashar Deeb, with a deep gash in his throat.

His father, Baker, spent eight years in Israeli prisons for activities in the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a violent group. He said he'd like Zakariya to attend university, but wouldn't talk him out of taking up arms.

"He is seeing suffering right now," he said of his son. "For 22 days, we were not able to sleep. He has witnessed the events by himself, so he, by himself, hates Israel."

Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Bryan Ross January 25, 2009 | 6:54 p.m.

And what about the Israeli children who have had to endure decades of suicide bombers and rocket attacks from the Palestinians? Why no mention of their trauma?

(Report Comment)
Ray Shapiro January 25, 2009 | 10:16 p.m.

Hamas brought it on their own. They also brought it onto the children of Israel...

Gaza Rockets Keep Israeli Children Living in Fear...
- "Mister Prime Minister, I want to tell you that the Qassam rockets make a frightful noise, my legs shake when I hear them, and my heart beats quickly... Mister Prime Minister, help us. Everything is difficult for us here. We want to live like the other children of Israel": this was the message delivered yesterday to Ehud Olmert by Orel Levi, a little girl who go to the fourth grade in an elementary school in Sderot (Neghev), the city most hit by Palestinian rockets in recent years. Olmert, in the city for an inspection, was very touched. Today, he called for a meeting in Jerusalem to examine the situation of the borders with the Gaza Strip. "I also told Olmert that life here wasn't fit for children" added the twelve year old Oren Elias from Sderot. "For the last eight years we have been bombarded. What can we do about it, forced to run from one safety zone to the next or the constant search for a 'betonada' (a protective cement block)?". "Olmert has not given us concrete responses, in general he has promised that he will increase the city's defences. But his visit - added Oren - was useful in any case. I think that he will do something now, because he has seen with his own eyes that the children living here are afraid of the Qassam rockets". "For example, I don't think it is right that my little sister, who is just five years old, should have to think about this kind of thing.

Israel, families still live in fear of Hamas rockets
A single father of four children, he has now sent his family to live farther north, out of the range of rocket fire.

“My children are scattered among family members. They don’t understand why this is happening. They are scared, they cry all the time and can’t sleep.

Hamas says that Israel has legitimised killing its children.
“I tell them there are good people and bad people in Gaza. The Palestinians are mostly good but the bad ones are doing horrible things. We cannot watch our children live under this threat. Two years ago I collected one friend in a body bag. Another friend was struck in the neck by shrapnel from a rocket and died in my arms.” There are no children left in Nahal Oz, he said, and those with the means to move their families have sought refuge from the 40-60 rockets that fall daily on Israel’s southern communities.

(Report Comment)
Ray Shapiro January 25, 2009 | 10:47 p.m.

More shabby journalism from the Associated Press
(Don't expect "fair and balanced" from AP's Karin Laub)
PMWATCH - April 21, 2003 -- The Associated Press continues to dish out shabby journalism, as the hollow piece on the killing of Palestinian Journalist Nazeh Darwazeh below from Karin Laub again amply illustrates.

A piece from Justin Huggler and Severin Carrell from the British Independent (see below) gives the crucial details that, "Mr. Darwazeh was wearing a bright yellow vest clearly marked 'Press'" when he was shot, that, according to Hassan al-Titi, a Palestinian cameraman for Reuters news agency who was standing beside Mr Darwazeh, "a soldier got out of an armoured car and knelt beside the tank. 'We shouted at him in Hebrew that we were journalists. Nazeh shouted and then I shouted.' But the soldier fired a single shot into the group of reporters", and that, also from Mr. al-Titi, "I looked and saw that [Nazeh's] head was damaged severely. His brain was hanging out of his skull."

Karin Laub's story, by contrast, gives the typical wooden-language AP depiction that Mr. Darwazeh "was killed while filming a confrontation between Israeli soldiers and Palestinians throwing stones and firebombs. Witnesses said Darwazeh was shot by an Israeli soldier taking cover behind an armored vehicle in an alley. The military insisted there were also Palestinian gunmen in the alley."

The fact that it was a single shot fired from a sniper, that the shot ended in the head of the journalist, that the victim was wearing a bright yellow jacket-- none of this makes it to the AP story!

Not only that, but nowhere in the AP story is any active attribution ever given to anyone for the killing of the journalist. Mr. Darwazeh "met his death" and "was killed while filming". Contrast this to the Independent's "he was shot in the head by an Israeli soldier".

Also worth noting is how the Independent’s piece puts this latest killing in context – how this is the second person shot in the head within a few days, the other person being British International Solidarity Movement activist, Tom Hurndall. None of this crucial context is given to us in the AP piece. Instead, we get the usual “contextualization” that is routinely pushed by the IDF, that “Nablus, the West Bank's largest city, has been one of the hotspots. As a militants' stronghold, it was the scene of frequent battles between Israeli troops and Palestinian gunmen.”

The Associated Press's dispatches are the main source for stories on the conflict for practically all the newspapers in the United States. Its deplorable coverage of the conflict is therefore replicated thousands of times across the United States, and the world.

(Report Comment)

Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.