Lawmakers try to tone down health care town halls

Tuesday, August 11, 2009 | 4:15 p.m. CDT; updated 11:12 a.m. CDT, Thursday, September 3, 2009
Sen. Arlen Specter, D-Pa., right, listens to Katy Abram, left, ask a question as the crowd reacts during a town hall meeting open to the public on Tuesday in Lebanon, Pa.

CLARKSTON, Ga. — Angry crowds have put many lawmakers on the defensive as they try to talk about health care with their constituents, leading some to replace public forums with teleconferences or step up security to keep protesters at bay.

The disturbances come at a critical time as lawmakers — mostly Democrats — return home for the August recess and host the meetings to boost support to overhaul the nation's costly health care system.


Related Media

Related Articles

In Georgia, Rep. Hank Johnson told his constituents not to be deterred by reports of "town halls gone wild," but the Democrat wasn't taking any chances at his first health care forum.

About 15 police officers — triple the normal security detail — were on duty Monday evening in case things took a turn. Guards filtered participants through a metal detector, audience members were warned that shouting would not be allowed, and the 500 in the crowd were told they would get no more than two minutes each to ask a question or make a comment.

"There have been some pretty heated town hall meetings thus far," said Johnson, who represents a suburban Atlanta district. "And I'm looking forward to breaking the mold."

Some Republicans have seized on noisy demonstrations that disrupted several meetings and clips of clashes posted to YouTube as a sign of lagging public support for President Barack Obama's top domestic policy priority. Obama held a forum on the issue in Portsmouth, N.H., on Tuesday.

Though there was some booing and cheering from people on both sides, Johnson's event turned out peaceful.

Maryland Sen. Ben Cardin had a tougher time Monday, forced to shout his way through a meeting in Towson, where angry constituents booed and jeered as the Democrat tried to explain the proposals moving through Congress.

On Tuesday, Sen. Arlen Specter stood through a slew of challenges from frustrated voters at a meeting in Lebanon, Pa. At one point, a burly officer stood immediately behind a man who angrily questioned the former Republican turned Democrat.

Some of the town halls have produced arrests and bitter protests. And at least one congressman canceled a forum after being targeted with a death threat. Rep. Brad Miller, D-N.C., said he will not host any town halls this month because he received a phone call threatening his life. Instead, he said he will hold one-on-one meetings with constituents.

Some Democrats have turned to teleconferences, which can reach more constituents than town halls — and be more easily controlled.

Rep. Brian Baird, D-Wash., said the "lynch mob mentality" surrounding the forums led him to hold a conference call last week instead of an in-person forum. The call attracted 6,000 constituents, a crowd he said was 10 times the size of a typical town hall meeting.

"When you see friends targeted by death threats, and you see well-meaning and well-intentioned people being shouted down, threatened, menaced, and our constituents suffering the same fate, it's frustrating," he said. "This is not American — it's dangerous."

Supporters of liberal groups and health care reform are organizing counter-protests. And Democrats are charging Republicans with sanctioning mob tactics and circumventing the process by fomenting made-for-TV shouting matches. In an article published Monday, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Majority Leader Steny Hoyer wrote: "Drowning out opposing views is simply un-American."

Still, many lawmakers have decided it's important to go forward with their meetings to win over reluctant constituents, in some cases opting to move to a bigger venue, adding security and extending the time for questions.

Rep. Niki Tsongas, D-Mass., moved her forum from a local supermarket to a gymnasium Saturday to brace for a bigger turnout. Tsongas spoke to a crowd of about 1,000 while flanked by police officers, but the debate remained civil.

In southeast Missouri, police officers in plain clothes mixed with the audience at two town halls hosted Monday by Democratic Sen. Claire McCaskill.

Another meeting she had scheduled for Tuesday was canceled by a suburban St. Louis school district after a public meeting last week hosted by Democratic Rep. Russ Carnahan ended with six arrests. But McCaskill plans to hold another event Tuesday night with an added hour for questions.

"Yeah, people have passionate feelings about this," she said. "But that's what a democracy is about."

Other forums have been more peaceful. Rep. Anthony Weiner's meeting last week was relatively quiet, but that may be because the New York Democrat's event wasn't publicized to reporters until a few hours before it started.

When some 500 people unexpectedly showed up at a forum by Democratic Rep. Eric Massa in western New York last week, the meeting had to be moved outdoors so it could accommodate everyone. Flashlights were pulled out as the sun went down.

Organizing for America, Obama's political operation, is urging supporters to visit the offices of members of Congress to express their support for a health care overhaul. The sessions are designed to counter the opposition by tapping into the president's extensive grass-roots network established during the 2008 campaign.

"We can't let extremists hijack this debate, or confuse Congress about where the people stand," the group said in an e-mail to supporters.

Baird, who said he's undecided about how he will vote on the measure, said he's held more than 300 town hall meetings over the last decade, and plenty of them have had unpleasant moments.

"But there was not this concerted effort to purposefully run people out of a room for the joy of a YouTube video," he said. "In that environment, it's counterproductive. And that's a shame."

Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Ray Shapiro August 11, 2009 | 7:21 p.m.

("Organizing for America, Obama's political operation, is urging supporters to visit the offices of members of Congress to express their support for a health care overhaul. The sessions are designed to counter the opposition by tapping into the president's extensive grass-roots network established during the 2008 campaign.")

I find it sad that the organization which helped get Obama elected continues to use this network as a top-down style of management discouraging any "free thinking" or "questioning" let alone any validation to "out of the Obama-box" suggestions to improve health care in America. Those who stand up, question or express concerns are laughed at and ridiculed by those we helped elect.
Manipulating us for continued blind obedience reeks of a cult.
Thank god I had no part in Jim Jones.

(Report Comment)
Hugo Orahilly August 16, 2009 | 10:43 a.m.

If Katy Abram and her husband do not want socialism in the USA than they should not use...

Public water and sewage systems, Public electricity grids, Public schools and univerisities, The INTERNET, Public streets, etc.... AND of course they must HATE our Publicly funded Military, Police and Firemen.

How can someone be so ungratefull of social services provided to themselves and not want others to live as well as they do by paying taxes that allow everyone an equal oppurtunity for sucess.

(Report Comment)
Charles Dudley Jr August 16, 2009 | 12:46 p.m.

Hugo Orahilly great post and totally correct but the blinded by their own greed and lusts to be like the Jones' has made them totally blind to the world around them.

Totally self centered and self serving only individuals.


All that really needs done is some reform and over hauling but it must be done correctly from the bottom up and not the top down. There is the point that all of our Government agencies fail at.

(Report Comment)
Jimmy Bearfield August 16, 2009 | 4:23 p.m.

People who don't carry their weight, including not paying income taxes, should not bite the hands that feed. Instead, they should humble themselves before those who pay the majority of the bills and not greedily demand that they pay even more.

(Report Comment)
Stan Swarts August 16, 2009 | 10:03 p.m.

Politicians want the power to administer health care to the people? However, the politicians don't want the same health care for themselves that they want to impose on the rest of the population. The politcians should fall under the same plan that they find for the rest of us. I for one am not willing to give up my freedom of choice. For America is and always shall be a democracy of the people and by the people, may GOD help us all.

(Report Comment)

Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.