Talk of Gabbert injury about more than physical condition

Saturday, October 31, 2009 | 6:53 p.m. CDT; updated 9:23 p.m. CDT, Saturday, October 31, 2009
Missouri quarterback Blaine Gabbert tries to escape a tackle by Anthony Perkins during the fourth quarter of Missouri's 36-17 victory over Colorado.

BOULDER, Colo. — Blaine Gabbert’s right ankle is getting healthier. Gabbert had 192 passing yards and two touchdowns in Missouri’s 36-17 win against Colorado Saturday.

Signs remain that Gabbert is still injured, if only slightly. He still isn’t running the ball as much as he did before he got hurt in the Tigers’ 27-12 loss to Nebraska. He had six carries Saturday for 32 yards. After a rare quarterback keeper Saturday, Gabbert hobbled back to the line of scrimmage to set up the team’s next play. After a sack, he slowly walked back to the line of scrimmage for the next play.

Other plays showed the improvement in his condition. After throwing an interception to Benjamin Burney, Gabbert chased after Burney. He caught up to him, but was unable to bring the player down. After the play, Gabbert didn’t seem to be hobbling on the ankle at all.

“(I’m) getting healthy again,” Gabbert said. “I’ve been feeling a lot better than I have been.”

Throughout the injury ordeal, Gabbert and coach Gary Pinkel have insisted the quarterback is fine. Gabbert was helped off the field Oct. 24 against Texas. After the game, Pinkel said Gabbert could have come back in if the score had been closer.

The following Monday, Pinkel said Gabbert was “OK,” later in the Texas game and could have gone back in. Shortly after Pinkel spoke, Gabbert was in the interview room wearing a cast on the ankle.

James Thomas has a unique perspective on why Gabbert and Pinkel would give that response. Thomas was a member of the Missouri football team in 2001 and 2002.

He is a doctoral student in sociology at Missouri. He taught Sociology of Sport for three semesters, a class at MU that looks at social issues in sports and how athletes relate to one another and to the culture around them.

“We can’t necessarily assume that, just because he says, ‘I’m fine,’ that he is,” Thomas said. “But we also can’t assume that, you don’t want to take the position that he doesn’t know his own body. You just want to make sure that you articulate that, one of the ways we can understand this is that he might not be able to express the pain that he’s in, because of his relationship to football and his relationship to the institution.”

Thomas said other members of a team play a role in a player’s answers to questions about injuries.

“He’s got training staff, he’s got his position coaches, he’s got other players,” Thomas said. “They’re also products, they also exist within this culture. So it’s not as if this culture is simply just formed from the top down. But it’s formed by everybody that’s around him as well.”

This leads to a system where the conduct of other players impacts a player’s behavior.

“He might see other players that are nursing through bruises and bumps,” Thomas said. “But if they’re also being told to play through pain, and they’re playing through pain, even though it might be more than be pain, it might be actually an injury, he is less likely to acknowledge that he’s injured. Because he needs to be a part of this impression that the team is kind of creating that part of being a good football player is playing when hurt.”

Other activities outside of sports create similar situations.

“The same reason that a lot of professors aren’t interested in a lot of students’ reasons for why, maybe, they missed a class,” Thomas said. “‘Do you have the sniffles or are you sick?’ is another way to think about that. But that’s also a product of a larger cultural system.”

While Thomas said of much of Gabbert’s pressure to not acknowledge pain comes from within the team, many of Pinkel’s pressures come from outside parties.

“Being a head coach goes way beyond just simply X’s and O’s, especially now,” Thomas said.  “A perfect example of that are those e-mails, those mass-generated kind of template e-mails that we get from Pinkel, the student body and the faculty get, saying ‘We appreciated you coming out for X whatever game it was, we want to continue to see you come.’ It’s always his signature. I doubt that he writes those e-mails. And even if he does, that actually might even prove the point even more. His job is beyond just X’s and O’s, he has to connect to the fan base.”

Connecting to the fan base includes projecting an image to fans that the team is on track to win.

“One of the ways they recognize when a team is not good or when they might lose interest is when their players are hurt,” he said. “So it’s very important that we at least give the perception that ‘He’s fine, he’s OK, he’s good to go. He is going to play. Because, for right now, for all intents and purposes, he is the face of the team.”

Thomas said the issue is intensified by the dismissal of Blaine Dalton earlier this season. Dalton was a highly recruited quarterback from Blue Springs South High School. With Dalton gone, Gabbert’s backup is Jimmy Costello, a quarterback from Liberty who came to Missouri as a walk-on.

“We don’t really necessarily have a backup that our fan base is familiar with, so it would be very, very detrimental,” Thomas said.  “From the team’s perspective it would be very detrimental to acknowledge that your quarterback is hurt because the fan base knows that you don’t have a backup.”

All of those factors, Thomas said, put Pinkel in a position where could he not admit a Gabbert injury.

“Putting in a backup quarterback that nobody knows is giving the impression that we’re going to go ahead and chalk this season up as a loss,” Thomas said. “And as a coach, he can’t do that. He’s got too much pressure.”

Thomas said the pressures Pinkel faces from external parties come to affect the pressure Gabbert faces internally.

“Gabbert is probably dealing with the effects of Pinkel managing those public relations,” he said. “He’s probably dealing with a lot of those effects internally by the ways in which that culture is being fostered with the team.”


Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Corl Leach November 1, 2009 | 5:42 p.m.

... by NOT playing Costello, even for a few plays when ahead by 30 pts, how is Pinkel going to justify to his fan base that Mizzou is on track to win anything? So far it's been the luck of the ankle and that's all.

If Costello is really so bad that he can't be trusted to run the offense for a few downs then get him off the team. Otherwise, play the man so he's at least seen the view before he's put on stage.

(Report Comment)
Nate Ratcliff November 3, 2009 | 9:18 a.m.

A responsible strategic view (i.e., head coach’s view) would have gotten Blaine healed as quickly as possible, particularly in a rebuilding year and regardless of the pressure. Does anyone think our record would have been any worse had Costello started against Ok State and Texas? Ok, frustrating but water under the bridge. Now we are in the manageable part of a rebuilding season and Blaine is still not mobile and one hit away from disaster. Coach Pinkel, I am a loyal fan of you and the team but please protect our vulnerable quarterback when future games are under control. Why else do you have a backup quarterback?

(Report Comment)

Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.