GUEST COMMENTARY: Missouri's minimum wage should not be capped

Thursday, March 3, 2011 | 5:12 p.m. CST

Many Missouri families are struggling in these tough economic times. Prices are rising on major U.S. commodities such as corn, flour, wheat and gasoline, putting even more stress on already strained budgets of many families. As of December, 9.5 percent of Missourians were unemployed.

That's why I find it odd that Jerry Nolte, a Republican representative from the 33rd District, has chosen not to work on ideas and legislation that can help bring good-paying, career-minded jobs to Missouri but instead has chosen to sponsor legislation to limit the state's minimum wage law, a law that 76 percent of us voted for in 2006.

Apparently the will of the people doesn't matter to Mr. Nolte or his co-sponsors — only the will of his political contributors (many of which are out-of-state, such as BNSF Railway of Fort Worth, Texas, and Comcast of Philadelphia). His argument is that our high-dollar minimum wage detracts from businesses coming to Missouri. Yes, that $7.25 per hour is just too much to be paying employees. After all, you can go to China and find people willing to work for 26 cents per hour.

On the other hand, Henry Ford was famous for paying his workers $5 a day at the turn of the 20th century — a wage that was almost double what others were paying at the time. He thought that he should pay his workers a decent enough wage so they might be able to afford the Model T car they produced. Today, minimum-wage workers are called the "working poor" for a reason — they can't afford to buy the goods that they produce and/or sell.

But Mr.Nolte seems to think that $15,080 per year (before taxes, assuming you work 40 hours a week for all 52 weeks a year at minimum wage) is just way too much to pay employees and must be stopped. The voters, they have told the press, didn't understand what we voted for.

That's right. According to them, the voters just don't have the mental capacity to understand what we are voting for. It doesn't matter if more than three out of four voters across the state said, "Yes, we want this." Mr. Nolte and his crew are going to tell us what is good for us.

That, my friends, is referred to in other countries as dictatorship — the government tells you what the laws will be, regardless of what you have to say.

The claim that if we don't repeal the minimum wage increase, businesses will leave is largely false because the majority of minimum-wage jobs are in service positions — think retail, fast food, restaurants, gas stations. First, those types of businesses can't leave because they must be in close proximity to their customers. Second, those businesses aren't what many of us would think of as gainful employment to begin with. Are we really supposed to believe that if we don't repeal the will of the voters of Missouri, all the quicky marts will just get up and leave overnight?

The people of Missouri stood up in 2006 and collectively said that we have respect for people who make minimum wage, and we want to make sure they have a safety net. We voted overwhelmingly to tie our state's minimum wage to the cost of inflation. Now, Mr. Nolte wants to overturn our vote and cater to big business donors. After all, every dime saved in employment costs is another dime for them.

We cannot allow Missouri — or any other state in this nation — to be turned into a totalitarian state where the will of the people is ignored or dictated to them. We cannot sit idly by and watch the poorest among us have their wages reduced so that corporate multimillionaires and shareholders can earn even more. We cannot — must not — forget that the person behind that counter making minimum wage is a human being as well and deserves respect and to be treated fairly, just like the rest of us. That person could be you or I at any time in our lives.

At a time when our economy is still reeling from the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression, Mr. Nolte wants to take even more money out of the economy. Don't forget that these minimum wage workers are also consumers — they buy goods and services just like the rest of us. If we decrease their pay, then it affects us all — from less taxes being collected to pay for roads and schools to fewer customers coming into our shops and businesses.

It's time to stand up and remind these politicians that they are here to represent us and not the interests of out-of-state political donors. It's time to let them know that "we, the people" are not going to be silenced and dictated to. It's a race to the bottom, and Missouri — America — is unfortunately winning.

Robert L. Stinnett lives in Boonville.

Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Jimmy Bearfield March 4, 2011 | 12:27 p.m.

"You can go to China and find people willing to work for 26 cents per hour."

And you can stay in Columbia and find lots of people willing to work for far less -- sometimes even for free -- than what they could garner in another town.

There are roughly 30,000 of these people. They're college students. They're educated, which is partly why employers like them. In some cases, they're only a semester or three from graduating, so by then they've obtained specialized skills that make them even more attractive to certain employers. When they graduate, some of them stay here, and if you're in their field, you sometimes have difficulty arguing for a raise when you know that your employer has a fresh crop of employees to choose from roughly every 16 weeks.

These folks put enormous downward pressure on wages. Such are the market forces.

(Report Comment)
bill crandell March 14, 2011 | 9:57 p.m.

Before using someone like Ford as an example you might want to check your facts as there is more to Ford and his $5 a day pay than meets the eye:

Henry Ford was one of the most reviled men in Detroit and Michigan, mainly because of his
treatment of his employees, his vehement opposition to labor unions, his political views and his abusive
treatment of his top managers, including his son, Edsel. Ford ran his automobile company in an
extremely rigid and autocratic manner, routinely firing subordinates with no warning or explanation.
In order for Ford’s workers to receive his famous $5-a-day pay rate, they had to prove themselves
“worthy” to inspectors of the Ford Sociological Department, which gave Henry Ford paternalistic
control over his employees. To prevent his employees from forming labor unions, Ford created the
Ford Service Department, a small army of strong-armed thugs who used violence and intimidation
to prevent unions from developing in Ford’s factories.
Ford didn’t shy away from making political statements. Through articles published in his newspaper,
The Dearborn Independent, Henry Ford made anti-Semitism “respectable” in the 1920s. In 91
consecutive issues, his paper blamed Jews for all of the world’s ills, a barrage that exposed Ford’s
radical views and forever marked him as anti-Semitic. He also opposed American involvement in
both World Wars, yet secured lucrative military contracts once war was declared, leading some to
view him as opportunistic.


Just sayin'

(Report Comment)

Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.