GUEST COMMENTARY: One genetically engineered crop doesn't change root causes of poverty

Monday, April 14, 2014 | 1:07 p.m. CDT

A recent Scientific American blog post blamed environmentalists for costing poor, malnourished people an estimated 1,424,000 life years in India alone.

Why? Because they presumably kept Golden Rice off the market for over a decade when it could have been helping the world’s poor during that time.

Golden Rice contains beta-carotene, a precursor of vitamin A. Rice doesn’t normally contain beta-carotene. Golden rice was created by genetic engineering: Scientists inserted genes from another species into its DNA.

According to that post by David Ropeik, Golden Rice was ready to go back in 2002, if it weren’t for those meddling tree-huggers. But, back then, you’d have to eat 20 pounds of the rice every day just to get a sufficient amount of vitamin A in your diet from it.

The technology has since improved. Now, someone could actually obtain their needed vitamins by eating a realistic amount of the colorful rice. But it’s dishonest to claim that lives were lost or harmed by not eating Golden Rice starting in 2002.

That said, after visiting peasant farmers on four continents, I’ve got a new perspective on hunger, malnutrition, and Golden Rice’s potential.

When I travel, I always ask families what they eat. In the Philippines, without fail, every family responded, “Rice.”

Just rice? An entire diet of rice? Hmm, maybe they need that Golden Rice.

Eventually, I tried a new approach: “What do you eat with your rice?”

The answer? Lots of things. Eggplant, bananas, squash, beans, taro, okra, sweet potatoes – even vitamin A-rich sweet potato leaves.

In Kenya, I’ve visited areas where the staple was white corn, not rice. Yet, like rice, white corn is not known for its abundance of vitamin A. But nobody I’ve met eats just corn. They eat beans, kale, pumpkin, sweet potatoes, and an abundance of African greens.

You see kale growing all over, even in urban slums. And it contains about two and a half times as much vitamin A as Golden Rice.

Nobody I have met in developing countries gets vitamin A from eating staple grains. Neither do Americans. Like us, they eat varied diets full of fruits and vegetables, many of which are rich in vitamin A.

Vitamin A isn’t rare in food. And it’s not the only nutrient that malnourished people worldwide lack.

The malnourished people I met in my travels did not only lack this nutrient or that one – they simply lacked food. Like a Kenyan school where many kids did without breakfast and lunch every day.

Some had to work in a quarry after school just to earn money to eat. Good bet those kids needed vitamin A — and every other vitamin, mineral, protein, fat, and just plain old calories.

Golden Rice isn’t the best solution in such cases. It’s solving the root causes of poverty and hunger. That means ending injustice and corruption, providing access to water, secure land tenure, and birth control, taking on the climate crisis, and dealing with HIV/AIDS, among other things.

Big Ag and biotech firms spent more than two decades developing Golden Rice. That gusher of money, time, and resources could have solved some of the broader, overarching and easy-to-fix problems peasant farmers face.

By focusing on the real, underlying problems instead of a narrowly defined nutrient deficiency, countless numbers of people could have enjoyed a higher standard of living.

Instead, biotech companies and people like Ropeik, who has ties to the biotech industry, attempt to reframe the debate as one about Golden Rice.

Golden Rice is simply a distraction the biotech industry dreamed up. It’s an expensive, non-solution to a serious problem and it’s merely designed to improve the image of other controversial genetically engineered crops in bigger markets, including the United States.

OtherWords columnist Jill Richardson is the author of Recipe for America: Why Our Food System Is Broken and What We Can Do to Fix It.  

Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Michael Williams April 14, 2014 | 1:57 p.m.

Jill makes the claim that the folks she talks to on her travels eat sufficient "other" crops to make Golden Rice unnecessary as a Vit A supplement. It's her main, if not only, argument against the crop...that "other" foods make up the difference.

Unfortunately, her "claim" is anecdotal evidence...that is, unscientific and uncontrolled. Her "evidence" flies in the face of numerous nutritional studies conducted by world bodies (such as WHO, see one such reference below) that say there are VERY REAL Vit A deficiencies in areas of the world where rice is THE staple food. Those same studies say that Jill's conclusion is simply untrue for a large proportion of folks; they DON'T eat Jill's claimed supplemental foods.

Indeed, Jill's conclusion is like saying there are no nutritional problems in the United States because we have such a variety of foods available to provide all needed nutrition. Well, you have to have access and eat it for it to do any good.

It appears Jill was simply talking to the wrong people....or at least not the same people sampled in those much more rigorous scientific studies.

See the figures on pages 12+.

(Report Comment)
Ellis Smith April 14, 2014 | 3:51 p.m.

It has rather quickly reached the point where one can read a few paragraphs of some of these tear jerkers and, without bothering to scroll to the bottom, correctly guess who the issuing organization is.

Damn those awful Capitalists at Pioneer (now DuPont Pioneer)! It's just scandalous how much of THEIR OWN (not taxpayers') money those people have wasted developing hybrid seed corn. Then they had the gall to make a profit on the results. Well, I never!

I chose Pioneer as an illustration for a reason. One of its founders, who was a United States Secretary of Agriculture and also a Vice President of the United States, was one of the most far out Leftist political figures during the latter 20th century. He and George Washington Carver were close friends.

(Report Comment)
John Schultz April 15, 2014 | 1:57 p.m.

Looks like she also wanted those biotech and crop companies to spend their money on things she wanted them to, instead of letting them act as independent bodies. The horror.

(Report Comment)

Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.