School bus drivers scrutinized

Convicted felon fired as concerns are raised about background checks
Monday, May 7, 2007 | 12:00 a.m. CDT; updated 9:25 p.m. CDT, Monday, July 21, 2008

No one can say for sure how many felons drive school buses for Columbia Public School District, but as of last week, the number dropped by one.

Deputy Superintendent for Administration Jacque Cowherd said a bus driver employed by First Student, the company the district contracts with to provide bus service, was fired last week as the result of a recent initiative to purge the bus driver ranks of certain convicted criminals. He said he did not know the name of the bus driver or what felony he was convicted of, although he thinks it had something to do with theft.

Cowherd said he did not want to know anything more than that a bus driver had been fired because of his felony background.

First Student Manager Denise Apperson did not return phone calls Friday, the company’s attorney Audrey Adams declined to comment, and public relations employee Jennifer Robinson did not return a phone call Friday.

Cowherd said state regulations allow people who have committed theft-related felonies to receive a school bus driver’s license, but the district has stricter standards.

He said that in January the district started a concentrated effort to ensure First Student was performing background checks on all of its bus drivers at least once a year, and then removing drivers with inappropriate criminal records. But he said he personally started looking over First Student’s shoulder last month after he was informed by state officials that a Missourian reporter had obtained the results of all bus driver background checks conducted by the Missouri Highway Patrol for the state Department of Education since 2005.

According to the Department of Revenue Web site, all school districts are required to perform fingerprint-based criminal background checks for all new bus drivers as of June 2005.

Department of Education data show that nearly half of all First Student bus driver applicants since 2005 have had been found to have criminal backgrounds.

However, the background checks are performed after the employee starts driving, and if they are found to have crimminal backgrounds, they should be let go.

But it remains unclear exactly how many felons drive buses for the district.

Cowherd said he knows of three other bus drivers who have committed felonies. He said they were arrested for passing bad checks, and the district will not press to have those drivers fired because they were not convicted of a felony that suggests they might present a danger to students, such as assault, driving while intoxicated or a sex offense.

First Student refused to provide the names of its bus drivers so the Missourian could run its own check. Lynn Barnett, assistant superintendent for student support services, said the district does not have the names of school bus drivers and would not ask ask First Student for such a list.

“We contract with First Student but we do not tell them who they can and cannot hire as bus drivers,” Barnett said via e-mail.

However, according to the district’s contract with First Student, the district does tell the bus company who can work as a bus driver. Exhibit E paragraph 20 of the contract states First Student shall ensure that all drivers “have no criminal record — no felonies or serious misdemeanors.”

Cowherd said he knows of no other bus drivers with serious criminal histories than the three mentioned earlier, but he said Blake Tekotte, the district’s transportation director, is still conducting a review of bus driver backgrounds. Tekotte said last month that normally he makes “random” examinations of First Student’s records and if he finds that an employee who has not passed a criminal background check is still driving a bus, he tells First Student management.

Asked last month how many bus drivers currently have criminal records, he said he hoped the answer was zero. But he said, “I wouldn’t be shocked if some slipped between the cracks.”

Despite the increased scrutiny of First Student employees, some people think the background checks and enforcement are still too lax.

Carla Findlay, a bus driver for First Student for seven years, said she has never undergone a fingerprint background check and knows of several other drivers who also have not been checked.

She said most bus drivers are upstanding people, but as a mother she would not want to put her children on a bus driven by a person who has not undergone a thorough criminal history check.

“Somebody could fall through the cracks, and that’s pretty scary,” Findlay said.

She said she does not think a bad check charge should prevent a person from driving a school bus, but she said a background check could ensure that people who have committed any crime against a child don’t get a job driving a bus.

“I don’t think those people should be driving a bus just like I don’t think they should be teaching school,” she said.

Ronald Cook, who drove school buses for First Student for 11 years before retiring last year, has encouraged the school district to fingerprint all First Student Employees. He said First Student avoids removing drivers who have failed background checks because the company has a hard time retaining drivers.

“First Student will hire anybody who can fit behind a wheel because they need a warm body,” he said. “The only reason I’m blowing the whistle is because they keep repeating the same mistakes. One of these days something is going to happen, and at least I can say I tried to stop it.”

Tekotte agreed that the bus drivers First Student employs are sometimes “not the cream of the crop.”

“It’s a challenge to get quality bus drivers,” he said. “This is my sixth year, and every year we’re short bus drivers.”

Like what you see here? Become a member.

Show Me the Errors (What's this?)

Report corrections or additions here. Leave comments below here.

You must be logged in to participate in the Show Me the Errors contest.


Michael Shearin May 9, 2007 | 1:16 p.m.

This article has brought gonzo journalism to a new low. Filled with hearsay, gossip, innuendo and outright slander, its’ author and Missourian staff should be ashamed to have printed it, let alone on the front page.

In the first place, the individual dismissed for having a felony on his record is one of the most dependable and capable individuals I’ve been privileged to work with. His felony occurred 18 years ago. Do you know anyone now who is the same as they were 18 years ago? This same person earlier this year, after dropping off his kids at school, witnessed an auto accident in which a car left the road, turned over and caught fire. He immediately radioed for emergency assistance. That being done, he secured his bus and removed the vehicle’s occupants while it was on fire, one of whom had a broken leg. Once emergency personnel arrived, he quietly returned to the bus lot without fanfare or recognition. Criminal indeed!

The rest of the article rests on the remarks of ill informed school board officials and disgruntled current/former employees who, lacking any effective self esteem, cannot feel worthwhile about themselves unless they are belittling someone else. Whatever happened to the adage, “If you don’t have anything good to say…”?

Lastly, M.B. Pell disgraces a group of hard working people who have to safely transport our most precious cargo to and from school under the most trying of circumstances. Inattentive motorists every day uncaringly cause more hazards too numerous to list here. Moreover, petulant children cause distractions and distractions cause accidents. The article only furthered several fallacies which do not need to be repeated. The truth is, school bus drivers as a class, love children beyond belief. Otherwise there would be more of a shortage then there is from time to time. It’s a difficult, often times thankless job. Nevertheless, it is most gratifying to see children year after year grow, mature, and move on with their lives.

I wish to extend the invitation to M.B. Pell to contact me direct for the opportunity to make amends. I have no reservation about anyone researching my background. They might be in for a few surprises.

Michael F. Shearin, Driver Bus Route 5

(Report Comment)

Leave a comment

Speak up and join the conversation! Make sure to follow the guidelines outlined below and register with our site. You must be logged in to comment. (Our full comment policy is here.)

  • Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language.
  • Don't use language that makes personal attacks on fellow commenters or discriminates based on race, religion, gender or ethnicity.
  • Use your real first and last name when registering on the website. It will be published with every comment. (Read why we ask for that here.)
  • Don’t solicit or promote businesses.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through. If you see something objectionable, please click the "Report comment" link.

You must be logged in to comment.

Forget your password?

Don't have an account? Register here.