You are the owner of this article.
featured

Three sisters, one laptop, slow internet: COVID-19 highlights differences in online learning in rural Missouri

  • 0
  • 4 min to read
A series of power lines connect to a single pole

Power lines connect to a single pole across the road from the Smith family home in Elkland. The Smith sisters — Kaylee, Ava and Reagan — share one computer among them while adjusting to classes that have moved online.

ELKLAND — Just shy of 11 a.m., sisters Kaylee, Reagan and Ava Smith pile into their father’s Jeep to make the 20-minute drive from their home to their Grandma Hartwell’s house in Marshfield.

Despite living in Elkland, the Smith sisters attend the Marshfield School District, which is nestled in Webster County and serves 2,917 students in town and the surrounding countryside.

As classes moved online because of COVID-19, the sisters have faced a set of problems. Their family has only one working laptop, and they live in an area where finding a stable internet connection is like finding a needle in a haystack.

Their house only has enough bandwidth to use one device at a time. They look forward to the beginning of the month, when their cellular data plan resets, offering up more chances to use the iPhones and smartwatches.

Once that is over, they are back to using a single device at a time.

Kaylee, Ava and Reagan Smith wait for Kaylee’s math homework to print

From left, Kaylee, Ava and Reagan Smith wait for Kaylee’s math homework to print at their grandmother’s home. The girls' house has limited internet access. When they are online, they can only use one device at a time. So they drive 20 minutes to grandma's house in town to print their schoolwork.

Ava Smith reads the first chapter of 'The Outsiders'

Ava Smith reads the first chapter of “The Outsiders” on April 14 during the drive home from her grandmother’s house. To read the book for her English class, she must print the book out one chapter at a time.

Senior year woes

Kaylee, a senior cheerleader, soccer player, alto saxophone player and member of the National Honor Society, will be attending Missouri State University in the fall to study criminology. Her last day of seated classes was March 13. Now, alongside the rest of the Class of 2020, she will finish her senior year from home.

“I never really reached the end. I never got actual closure,” she said. “There’s nothing anyone can do that’s going to give me my senior year of high school back.”

The girls arrive at their grandma’s house, where Kaylee immediately heads to the back room to print her homework.

The house sits in Marshfield proper and has a stronger internet connection. A few minutes in, she learns she also has a quiz to complete. It’s not yet available — she’ll have to return after lunch to print it.

Ava Smith crosses the small bridge

Ava Smith crosses the small bridge linking her family’s field to the small island in the Smith family pond. Ava had ventured onto the island to try and get a look at the geese nesting there.

Driving through Marshfield, you wouldn’t guess there was a stay-at-home order in place. Lunch-hour traffic is as heavy as pre-COVID days. The line through the McDonald’s parking lot is long.

Reagan compares it to the line at Dairy Queen, where she spends her weekday afternoons at the drive-thru window as an essential worker. While she appreciates having a job, she thinks that fast-food restaurants should close for the time being.

“I don’t think fast food is essential during all this,” Reagan said. “Nobody is going to stay home if we don’t start shutting places down.”

Triptych of the Smith sisters

Three sisters, one online device at a time. LEFT: Kaylee Smith is a senior at Marshfield High School and one of many in the Class of 2020 who had their final year altered by COVID-19. Before campus was closed, she had been looking forward to her senior soccer season. Earlier in the day, she had decided to change into her uniform. The team would have played that night had the season not been canceled. TOP RIGHT: Ava Smith is an eighth-grader at Marshfield Junior High, though her eighth-grade year is done. Having passed all her classes, any work she continues to do is voluntary and can only raise her grades. She continues to work, mainly, on a biomedical science class, citing her desire to someday be a surgeon. BOTTOM RIGHT: Reagan Smith is a junior at Marshfield High School, where she continues to take classes despite having limited access to the internet. Her biggest worry, she said, is that the lockdowns will force her senior year to start online. 

Reagan is a junior and is enrolled in a college-level government class. It’s been one of her main priorities since the high school campus closed. The lively atmosphere of the discussion-based class hasn’t been the same, according to Reagan. Valuable time and bandwidth must be used for her to log into the class’s online discussion board, where only a few people will have contributed opinions.

“One small thing takes a lot of internet at our house,” she said.

While worrying about her current classes, Reagan has not confirmed her final schedule for next year. She is concerned that the lockdowns may force her senior year to begin off-campus.

“That’s the one thing that worries me the most,” she said.

The playhouse and swingset combo

A small redbud tree blooms behind a playhouse and swing set in the Smiths' backyard.

Prioritizing internet access

The trio grabs lunch and heads back to Grandma Hartwell’s house so Kaylee can print the quiz she was waiting for. Reagan opts to stay a while longer before heading into work. Ava prints out the first chapter of “The Outsiders” for her English class to read on the ride home.

An eighth-grade student who has passed all her classes, Ava could be done for the year. For students not enrolled in dual-credit college classes, the school district is allowing third-quarter grades to stand as final grades. Any assignment not turned in or that would lower a student’s grade is exempted. All her classes are now voluntary.

Ava Smith, left, and Kaylee Smith work on their separate homework assignments

Ava Smith, left, and Kaylee Smith work on their separate homework assignments at their home in Elkland. Ava studied for her biomedical science class, while Kaylee worked on college algebra.

She’s decided to continue working on her English class and a biomedical science “medical detectives” class. Ava said she loves that class and wants to be a surgeon someday.

Because her classes are optional, Ava is often shoved to the back of the sisters’ internet priority line. She says that is fair.

“I do realize their classes are more important,” she said.

Deanne Hartwell, Kaylee Smith, Ava Smith and Reagan Smith

From left, Deanne Hartwell and grandchildren Kaylee Smith, Ava Smith and Reagan Smith sit around Hartwell’s kitchen table to make plans for lunch.

‘Doing as much as they can’

The car pulls back into the driveway. Kaylee heads inside, sets her book and papers on the table and claims the laptop to FaceTime a friend for help with the math homework.

Math isn’t Kaylee’s best subject, but she must continue working on this college-level course. Still, she finds it frustrating as she teaches herself without the added resources the internet has to offer other students.

Without internet access, “I don’t have the help that I need,” Kaylee said. “My teacher said we could do Zoom conference calls, but I don’t know if my internet is strong enough,” she said.

For any one person to Zoom, or check email, or any other digital chore, the internet speed prohibits anyone else from going online.

Kaylee Smith’s math homework and notes are spread out

Kaylee Smith’s math homework and notes are spread out on the family’s kitchen table. With most of her classes now voluntary, this college-level algebra course is the only class she must continue to work on for credit.

ABOVE: A light bulb hangs from the ceiling in a bathroom in the Smiths’ home. The family has been working on remodeling the bathroom for some time, but the extra time home has given them a chance to focus on painting it — a task undertaken by Ava Smith. Photographed April 14, 2020.

Twenty percent of students in the Marshfield district do not have adequate access to the internet, according to counselor Amanda Badgett. Laptops and other devices were given to some students. A list was created of all the students who didn’t have adequate access. Students are also mailed packets of homework assignments at the start of each week.

“I feel like they’re doing as much as they can,” Kaylee said.

Kaylee and Ava Smith prepare music for their daily run

Kaylee, left, and Ava Smith prepare music for their daily run. The girls run every day, either with one another or with a friend.

After finishing her schoolwork, Ava moves to the bathroom she is helping to remodel in her spare time. A family friend, home from college, drops by to say hello, and she continues work on an essay — no internet required. The girls’ mom claims the laptop to look up a recipe for dinner.

As night falls, so does the internet speed. In a time when everyone is staying home and going online, bingeing shows, meeting up in virtual hangouts and attending online classes, the Smith sisters are left waiting, their screens still buffering.

Kaylee Smith walks toward family friend Jeydon Jones, sister Ava Smith and the family dog Sadie

After the group spent time down by the Smith family pond, Kaylee Smith, left; family friend Jeydon Jones, center; Ava Smith, right; and Sadie, the family dog, return through the gate on the way home.

For more COVID-19 related news, see our section dedicated to COVID-19 updates.
  • Photo Editor for Spring 2020. Reach me at hjtr43@mail.missouri.edu

  • I'm the Director of Photography working close with staff photographers, videographers, photo editors and designers to help our stories become visually exciting. Follow us on Instagram: comissourian

Recommended for you

Join the conversation

When posting comments, please follow our community guidelines:
• Login with a social account on WorldTable.
• Don't use obscene, profane or vulgar language or engage in personal attacks.
• Stay on topic. Don’t hijack a forum to talk about something else or to post spam.
• Abuse of the community could result in being banned.
• Comments on our website and social media may be published in our newspaper or on our website.